Today two New York press conferences addressed the issues behind the movie Blood Diamond. In one way, they couldn’t have been more different. The first, held in the Open Society Institute, was organized by Global Witness and Amnesty International. It addressed flaws in the Kimberley Process and the atrocities that took place in Sierra Leone in the late 1990s and the conflict going on today in Angola and the Democratic Republic of Congo. They asked for government oversight and auditing of every diamond purchase. Filmmaker Sorious Samura showed ninety seconds of his upcoming documentary on conflict diamonds where he easily sells rough diamonds with no paperwork to sleazy guys on 47th Street in New York. A scattering of television cameras and a few consumer journalists puzzled through talk of the Kimberley Process, with one T.V. cameraman worried that the footage was not sufficiently dramatic asking in frustration: “Could you tell us about the suffering that diamonds cause?”
The second press conference two hours and two blocks away in the glossy Mandarin Oriental of Time Warner Center was packed with journalists and cameramen from the realms of music, fashion, culture, and, of course, jewelry. Russell Simmons, with a wall of slogans behind him a la Bush, spoke about his fact-finding trip to Southern Africa and the benefits that diamonds have on the economy of Botswana and South Africa. He stressed the fact that 85 percent of the revenue from Botswana’s diamonds went to the people of Botswana and discussed his new Diamond Empowerment Fund. The managing director of Debswana, Botswana’s mining company, spoke about the benefits diamonds bring to the economy. The first question came from a gossip columnist from the New York Post, asking Simmons where his wife was and whether or not they were still married.
Although these press conferences came from two perspectives on the issue, they had one thing in common. They demonstrated why a complex issue is not best discussed through the prism of celebrity and celebrity culture.
This pot has been well stirred by the media circus surrounding Blood Diamonds, of course. Neither of these press conferences would have happened without the news hook of the movie. But it was pretty clear from the questions that no one in the consumer media really knows or cares much about these issues and that all the media attention about conflict diamonds isn’t generating much understanding.
So how will consumers react to all the noise? Those who care will probably follow Leonardo DiCaprio’s advice to ask retailers to show them their policy showing that they don’t carry conflict diamonds. Then promptly forget about it.

